Coffee: social ritual, intellectual stimulant, and subtle Ally of mental health

Cultural, social, and philosophical dimensions

Coffee is not just a drink: it stands as a cultural institution, an ancient ritual, and a symbol of gathering. In Enlightenment Europe, literary cafés fostered the emergence of the bourgeois public sphere described by Jürgen Habermas (Strukturwandel der Öffentlichkeit, 1962), where free thought and social critique thrived. Yet the phenomenon extends far beyond the West: in Ethiopia, the birthplace of coffee, the buna ceremony remains a daily communal ritual. In the Arab world, qahwa was linked to poetry, spiritual reflection, and scholarly exchange (Hattox, 1985), while in Turkey, coffee is recognized by UNESCO as Intangible Cultural Heritage (UNESCO, 2013).

Even today, the coffee break serves as a temporal marker and a social anchor in workplaces and daily life. It is not merely a gustatory pleasure: it fulfills needs of social cohesion, time regulation, and intellectual stimulation.

I. Evidence-based benefits confirmed by research

Mood and Depression Prevention
Numerous studies converge: moderate consumption (2–3 cups/day) appears associated with a reduced risk of depression. Grosso et al. (2016, Molecular Nutrition & Food Research), in a meta-analysis of over 340,000 participants, reported a dose-dependent effect, with about 8% risk reduction per additional cup. Lucas et al. (2011, Archives of Internal Medicine) confirmed a relative 20% decrease in depression risk among women consuming 4 cups daily over 10 years.

These results should be interpreted cautiously: the association is not causal, and lifestyle factors may contribute to the correlation. Some recent work even suggests a plateau effect beyond 3–4 cups (Wierzejska, 2021).

On a biological level, the mechanism is clearer: caffeine blocks adenosine receptors, promoting the release of dopamine and norepinephrine — neurotransmitters essential to energy, motivation, and psychological vitality (Juliano & Griffiths, 2004). Coffee also contains antioxidants, protective against inflammatory processes implicated in psychiatric disorders.

Protective Effects Against Cognitive Decline
Recent research suggests that regular coffee consumption may slow cognitive decline and reduce biomarkers associated with Alzheimer’s disease (Gardener et al., 2021). Umbrella reviews, such as Poole et al. (2017, BMJ), confirm a general association between moderate coffee intake and lower risk of cognitive decline or dementia.

However, results vary by cohort and methodology, and no definitive causal proof exists. Benefits should therefore be considered as a probable protective trend, not as certainties.

II. Risks and limitations — the requirement of moderation

Anxiety and Sleep Disturbances
Above 400 mg of caffeine/day (≈ 4–5 cups), harmful effects become predominant: nervousness, restlessness, insomnia. This threshold is consistent with the opinion of the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA, 2015).

Timing matters: late-day consumption (after 2–3 pm) can disrupt melatonin secretion and impair sleep onset (Sleep Foundation, 2022). Genetic differences also play a role: individuals with certain CYP1A2 polymorphisms metabolize caffeine more slowly and are more prone to anxiety (Cornelis et al., 2018).

Tolerance, Dependence, and Interactions
Regular consumption induces progressive tolerance: the stimulating effects diminish, sometimes prompting dose escalation. Withdrawal illustrates a mild but real dependence (symptoms include headaches, irritability, fatigue) (Juliano & Griffiths, 2004). However, caffeine dependence remains moderate and cannot be compared to that of alcohol, nicotine, or opioids.

Finally, caffeine may interact with psychiatric medications, amplifying or reducing their effects (notably antidepressants, anxiolytics, stimulants). This justifies medical supervision when necessary.

III. Individual variability and lived experiences

Testimonies illustrate this diversity:

• Claire, a teacher, optimizes her focus with a morning coffee but experiences anxiety if she drinks it in the afternoon.

• Karim, a consultant, noticed that overconsumption during a stressful period severely worsened his insomnia.

These examples remind us that sensitivity to coffee depends on biological (genetics, metabolism), psychological (stress, anxiety), and contextual factors, making individual adaptation essential.

IV. Summary Table — Effects by level of consumption

Observed EffectModerate (2–3 cups/day)High (>5 cups/day)Risk of depressionDecrease (8–20%)Benefits canceled or reversedRisk of anxietyLow / absentStrong increaseCognitive decline / Alzheimer’sSlowed (probable)Not documentedSleep qualityLittle impact (if before 2 pm)Frequent disruptionCognitive performanceTemporary improvementDecline via toleranceDependence / withdrawalRare, mildFrequent (headaches, irritability)

V. Social and organizational dimensions

Beyond biological effects, coffee regulates social rhythms:

• A convivial pause in offices, a moment of cohesion.

• A stimulant for collective creativity, a catalyst in brainstorming sessions.

• A breathing space in the middle of a workday.

Yet this role is ambivalent: coffee can also reinforce a culture of constant productivity, serving as an artificial crutch rather than a chosen ritual of pleasure.

VI. Practical recommendations

• Do not exceed 3–4 cups/day (≤ 400 mg caffeine), as recommended by EFSA (2015).

• Prefer morning consumption; avoid after 2 pm to preserve sleep quality.

• For anxious or insomniac individuals: limit to 1–2 cups.

• Consider alternatives that maintain conviviality: decaffeinated coffee, herbal teas, rooibos, light teas.

• Extra caution for those on psychiatric treatment — consult a physician if in doubt.

Conclusion

Coffee remains at once an intellectual, social, and physiological drink. Heir to millennia-old traditions, it stimulates thought and fosters conviviality, while carrying a profound ambivalence: a protective ally at moderate doses, a disruptive factor when consumed in excess.

Its benefits on mood and cognition are scientifically documented but remain associative, not absolute proof of causality — avoiding overpromising is essential.

Coffee ultimately underscores the need for balance: between pleasure and mild dependence, performance and rest, the individual and the collective. Understanding its complexity requires combining:

• scientific rigor,

• awareness of one’s physiological sensitivity,

• and societal reflection on the pace of life.

Reframing coffee as a chosen and shared pleasure — rather than forced stimulation — restores its rightful place: a companion of thought, a facilitator of connection, but never a substitute for rest or inner serenity.

References

• Grosso G. et al., Molecular Nutrition & Food Research, 2016.

• Lucas M. et al., Archives of Internal Medicine, 2011.

• Juliano LM, Griffiths RR., Psychopharmacology, 2004.

• Poole R. et al., BMJ, 2017 (umbrella review).

• Wierzejska R., Nutrients, 2021.

• EFSA Panel on Dietetic Products, Nutrition and Allergies. EFSA Journal, 2015.

• Sleep Foundation, “Caffeine and Sleep”, 2022.

• Cornelis MC et al., JAMA, 2018.

• Habermas J., Strukturwandel der Öffentlichkeit, 1962.

• Hattox R., Coffee and Coffeehouses, 1985.

• UNESCO, “Turkish Coffee Culture and Tradition”, 2013.

Mardès, a house of publishing, culture, and transmission
Mardès is an inclusive and modern house that edits poetry collections, essays, magazines, and works on the art of living. It also creates cultural and artistic events that foster reflection and sharing.
Its mission is twofold: to edit and to transmit — transmitting poetry, thought, and the gestures of daily life that ease existence and enrich sensitivity.
Through its support, several Musarthis contents remain freely available, affirming a generous and elegant vision of culture.

Supported by the publishing and cultural house Mardès, and by the poetry collections Cafésis, which celebrate coffee as an art of living — a space of quiet intensity and shared elegance.

the boutique